‘There’s a human element to all deals’

Faiza Saeed glides into her seat at Le Bernardin, in her component among the many Manhattan energy lunchers. Clad in a leopard-print shirt and black trousers, the poised company lawyer explains that the Michelin three-star institution is a daily hang-out, despite the fact that Cravath, Swaine & Moore, the elite “white shoe” agency that she runs, has lately moved workplaces and is not a straightforward stroll away.

Saeed has simply been honoured at a star-studded dinner, alongside monetary knowledge baron Michael Bloomberg and actor-director Ron Howard, as “a principal architect of the fashionable media panorama” due to the quiet steering she has supplied to chief executives for many years. Half a dozen world moguls, together with Disney’s Bob Iger, former Vivendi chief Jean-Marie Messier and Richard Plepler, former chief government of HBO, paid tribute to the 58-year-old’s skill to whisper them via high-stakes moments, from negotiating landmark offers to defanging activist buyers. 

Howard Schultz, former chief government of Starbucks, informed the glittering meeting that he had been turning to Saeed for greater than 20 years, and “in each single instance, as God is my witness, her recommendation and counsel has helped the corporate and helped me be a greater particular person . . . She will learn a room higher than anybody you’ve ever met.”

The actual room the place we’re assembly is coolly elegant, dominated by a big ocean seascape that nods to Le Bernardin’s give attention to fish. The well-spaced tables, sound-deadening carpets and the light clink of plates and silverware create a digital cocoon, good for discreet dialog.

Saeed loves its “gracious” understated mien and waiters who can often be relied on to not fawn over her big-name purchasers. “You even have the prospect to be good since you’re consuming fish, despite the fact that you’re consuming 18,000 energy,” she says with a smile.

We contemplate the menus: the necessary three-course meal begins with a alternative amongst “nearly uncooked” or “barely touched” starters, whereas the mains are “flippantly cooked”. After I ask for suggestions, she says: “I all the time get the artichoke and one of many fish.” I go for tuna tartare with sea urchin adopted by crimson snapper.

We’re assembly on Juneteenth, a US federal vacation, and neither of us has to return to the workplace, so we ask the sommelier to suggest glasses of applicable wine. He suggests a Portuguese white for me and gently overrides Saeed’s suggestion of a Riesling, saying crimson burgundy would pair higher along with her halibut.

She acquiesces with a shrug: “I by no means would have guessed that halibut would go together with crimson. It sounds a bit revolutionary.”

Company legislation will not be a discipline for the weak or the squeamish. Dominated largely by brash, tough-talking males, it routinely requires working all night time at brief discover and in secrecy in opposition to not possible deadlines. The purchasers — formidable executives, aggressive personal fairness barons and cocky buyers — are sometimes deaf to recommendation they don’t need to heed. The underlying transactions, from mergers and acquisitions to preliminary public choices and proxy fights, make and lose fortunes, form the worldwide financial system and decide the fates of thousands and thousands of employees.

For many years, Cravath, famed for its blue-chip consumer checklist, not solely had a hand in most of these offers, however set the usual for American company legislation: companies throughout the nation would look ahead to it to announce the dimensions of annual pay rises and benchmark their very own salaries accordingly. 

You discover ways to settle for that there are two sides to every part and your job is to know the way to marshal your arguments, whichever facet you’re tasked with arguing for

Working there for 33 years has put Saeed — in phrases that she borrows from the musical Hamilton — in “the room the place it occurs” for a few of the most infamous company occasions of the previous three many years. A junior companion in the course of the 2000 negotiations over the $350bn AOL-Time Warner merger, typically dubbed the worst deal of all time, she had graduated to trusted adviser for Vivendi’s 2000s acquisitions spree and determined money crunch in the identical decade.

Once we meet, she has lately helped Iger rating a serious victory in his bitter and costly battle with activist investor Nelson Peltz and is advising the Paramount unbiased administrators on their negotiations with Skydance Media. “Everyone thinks about it as massive personalities and egos . . . however there’s additionally a human component to all offers,” she says. 

The toughest particulars to nail down in any negotiation are about folks, about who will get what title, who stays on and who will get pushed out, she says. “You’re there to provide them recommendation. In some methods you’re in a position to be extra goal in serving to them navigate what they’re going through. However you can also deliver empathy and understanding at a human stage of what they’re going via.”

Whereas we nibble on the amuse-bouche, a tiny salmon rillette with a thimbleful of carrot and ginger soup, Saeed tells me that legislation wasn’t her first plan. Raised in northern California by Pakistani immigrants, she initially needed to sing professionally. However the adrenaline rush she received from warbling torch songs à la Barbra Streisand at expertise exhibits wore off too rapidly.

She interned with a San Francisco radio station and graduated from highschool early to attend a area people school. After transferring to the flagship College of California campus at Berkeley in 1985, she studied molecular biology however discovered laboratory work lonely and began studying the enterprise pages. It was the period of company raiders that might later be memorialised in Barbarians on the Gate, the bestselling e book concerning the personal equity-backed buyout of RJR Nabisco, and Saeed was hooked. 

She added a second main in economics and went to Harvard Regulation College, which was an adjustment for a former scientist. “You discover ways to settle for that there are two sides to every part and your job is to know the way to marshal your arguments, whichever facet you’re tasked with arguing for,” Saeed remembers.

Company legislation was her jam, and Cravath, regardless of its near-total dearth of feminine position fashions and a fame for demanding terribly onerous work, proved irresistible. Her very first deal concerned a subsidiary of KingWorld, the corporate behind the sport exhibits Jeopardy! and Wheel of Fortune, with the daddy of tennis participant John McEnroe main the authorized group on the opposite facet.

In one other early transaction, the sale of the Onerous Rock Cafe chain to Rank, the senior lawyer put Saeed in control of advising the chain’s restricted companions. At some point the telephone rang, and it was Ben Stein, the famously grumpy actor and economics commentator, demanding particulars about his funding. “It was fairly daunting. He’s a troublesome cookie . . . However you then dwell via it, and that’s fairly superior,” she remembers.

“A part of being an expert is dealing with not understanding every part and nonetheless having to determine and provides recommendation,” she says. “Typically you must react within the second. And I feel it makes you resilient.”

By the point the deft waiters have poured sauces over our starters, Saeed is telling me about representing Time Warner because it scrambled to deal with the arrival of the web. It was 1999 and Google was a mere start-up, whereas digital portal America On-line had momentum and cachet. Time Warner’s world-famous magazines, film studio, cable division and the HBO tv community introduced in additional income and employed way more folks than AOL, however its executives have been dying to do a deal. 

Negotiations have been stored so secret that most individuals at Time Warner felt blindsided. “The impetus for the deal wasn’t mistaken . . . They precisely recognized the priority that the web was going to be a disruptive know-how,” Saeed says. “However when it was introduced, the primary place I heard from was HBO and so they weren’t blissful about it. They mentioned, ‘What the heck have you ever guys performed?’”

Issues went downhill from there: the mixed firm reported the most important annual company loss in historical past, and AOL was later revealed to have been inflating its promoting income.

A hostile [bid] is as a lot a psychological battle as an actual one. A part of what you’re demonstrating to the bidder is that you simply’re in for an actual struggle

Years later, when the corporate had gone again to calling itself Time Warner, Saeed stood beside chief government Jeff Bewkes as he fought a hostile takeover by twenty first Century Fox. “Everyone form of counted us out as a result of, they mentioned, no one’s going to prevail in opposition to Rupert Murdoch,” she says. 

On Saeed’s recommendation, Bewkes and the board refused to be rushed, and adjusted the foundations to stop Fox from calling a particular shareholder assembly. “After they leaked the supply, we have been prepared. We had our press launch rejecting it out actually in minutes,” she remembers. “Issues like that may make an actual distinction as a result of a hostile [bid] is as a lot a psychological battle as it’s a actual one. A part of what you’re demonstrating to the bidder is that you simply’re in for an actual struggle.” 

The waiter gently drizzles my crimson snapper and asparagus with an emulsion based mostly on unripe grapes. I gobble it down. Saeed eats her halibut in crimson wine sauce quite extra daintily as she recollects the disaster on the animation firm DreamWorks. Simply months after its preliminary public providing in autumn 2004, the corporate’s revenues and share value have been plunging, and the US Securities and Trade Fee had began an investigation. Saeed knew she needed to seize management of the scenario.

“You possibly can find yourself with a runaway board the place they type of panic,” she says. “It’s very, essential as an adviser to supply all of them the data they want, but additionally the reassurance that that is going to be handled.”

Her secret is to keep in mind that company bigwigs are human beings like everybody else: “They convey insecurities and stress, and everyone’s nervous about their fame. You must perceive the stress that they’re going via and redouble your efforts to be the calming presence.”

She additionally tries to maintain her purchasers out of bother in different methods, reminding them to make use of e mail quite than texts to speak about contentious enterprise points as a result of a lot leads to litigation. Not solely is it much less invasive to have e mail collected from a server than to have to show over a telephone for screenshots, however emoji-laden texts can look unprofessional to a choose or jury. 

Ever discreet, Saeed not often names the purchasers she advises, befriends and even joins for holidays. However Schultz has mentioned publicly that he was so impressed by the best way she took cost on the first DreamWorks board assembly he attended that he chased her down afterwards to ask her to work with Starbucks.

And after I known as DreamWorks co-founder Jeffrey Katzenberg after the lunch date, he confirmed that he had relied on Saeed to educate him via “very charged, emotional and difficult” choices, as a result of he might rely on her for empathy but additionally straight speak. “She has the subtlety of a shotgun. Each barrels coming at you without delay, and I couldn’t be extra appreciative of that,” Katzenberg mentioned. “You solely get the unvarnished reality from her.”

Saeed has scrupulously averted a sculptured mound of what appears to be like like mashed potatoes and barely touched her wine. She is saving room for dessert. “It’s all the time so disappointing whenever you include a consumer and so they say, no, no dessert. You simply take a look at them and say, ‘ we’re paying for a three-course menu’,” she says.

Simply then the waiters current us with an additional deal with not talked about within the three-course menu. “They don’t all the time do that,” Saeed says. We dip tiny spoons into a virtually complete egg shell that has been refilled with chocolate mousse and caramel. (After I verify the invoice later, I discover that the maitre d’ has comped us the $38 signature candy, with a be aware that the low cost code is “SAEED”.)

It’s been two-and-a-half hours to date, and we have now talked nearly solely about work. After I ask what else is necessary to her, she initially deflects. “Lots of my pricey buddies are folks I work with,” she says. “Purchasers particularly have grow to be my true buddies.”

Pressed, Saeed admits she is attempting to select up enjoying the piano once more after years of neglect and confesses to being a Spotify addict, regardless of being a “late adopter”. For train, she does yoga and walks in Central Park, close to her Higher East Facet condo. 

As we tuck into our official desserts, a dome of pistachio praline for Saeed and hazelnut cream in a tiny chocolate waffle cone for me, the dialog turns again to extra snug territory.  

Tactically, perhaps the good factor to do can be to take the chance, roll the cube. However the particular person you’re advising goes to dwell with the choice

Has something modified within the 30 years that Saeed has been advising chief executives? Sure, she says, as a result of the legislation in Delaware, the place most massive US corporations are included, has developed, significantly across the issues corporations can do to fend off hostile bids and activist challenges.  

“They’ve made it much less and fewer enjoyable as a result of they’ve taken away all of the enjoyable issues that you might actually do, the artistic, difficult, intelligent defences,” she recollects with apparent nostalgia. Delaware judges now frown on “crown jewels” facet offers that forestall takeovers by giving management over key belongings to a 3rd occasion, and so they not let boards stagger director elections to make it onerous to exchange them.

That jogs my memory to ask about Elon Musk’s current choice to reincorporate Tesla in Texas, after the Delaware courts threw out his $56bn pay bundle. Saeed partly demurs, as a result of Cravath defended the corporate in that case, however opines that Delaware is unlikely to lose its standing as “the centre of gravity for company legislation”.

The tiny US state attracts a lot of its tax income from the enterprise of regulating enterprise, so it has an enormous stake in offering knowledgeable judges, clear statutes and predictable outcomes for corporations that incorporate there. “The legislature actually seeks to guard its benefit . . . That’s been true for 50 years,” she says. “It’s an enormous funding that is smart for them. However for an enormous state there’s lots of different political forces.”

Because the dialog winds down, I ask what Saeed thinks about the way forward for the authorized career. It’s a topic she ponders, as she begins her third time period as Cravath’s presiding companion. The primary lady to carry the position, she has overseen two gigantic shifts. In 2021, Cravath lastly deserted the strict “lockstep” system that paid companions purely on seniority and started rewarding its high performers. Extra lately, she led the agency’s transfer from its iconic pyramid-topped workplace tower in Hells Kitchen to Hudson Yards. 

Eight years of managing have given Saeed way more endurance with purchasers who fail to take her recommendation and overpay for acquisitions or fail to completely press their benefit in powerful negotiations. “Tactically, perhaps the good factor to do can be to take the chance, roll the cube,” she says. “However the particular person you’re advising goes to personal and dwell with the choice . . . [They] must determine what, of the entire completely different transferring components, are necessary.”

Le Bernardin has largely emptied. As we put together to stroll out, Saeed tells me she is off to purchase a necktie as a present for a buddy’s birthday. She additionally lets slip a remark that displays how a lot of an ordeal it has been for this consummate behind-the-scenes skilled to face private questions for greater than three hours: “It was enjoyable . . . [but] let’s come again after we can actually benefit from the meals.”

Brooke Masters is the FT’s US monetary editor

Discover out about our newest tales first — comply with FT Weekend on Instagram and X, and subscribe to our podcast Life & Artwork wherever you pay attention