Keep knowledgeable with free updates
Merely signal as much as the Renewable power myFT Digest — delivered on to your inbox.
The author is a professor within the Institute for Housing and City Analysis at Uppsala College and writer of ‘The Worth is Fallacious: Why Capitalism Gained’t Save the Planet’
The view that the world is lastly profitable within the power transition away from fossil fuels is more and more distinguished. It tends to be buttressed by charts displaying “exponential progress” globally in renewable-power capability and era in recent times.
Comforting as this take could also be, we have to throw chilly water over it. We’re emphatically not but profitable, and it’s time to cease pretending that we’re.
Taking a look at international renewables progress charges is massively deceptive. There’s not one single power transition however a collection of regional transitions of broadly various type, tempo and scope. The outsized materiality of 1 — China’s — means international figures veil greater than they reveal. They presently look spectacular as a result of, and solely as a result of, China’s do.
In 2023, based on figures printed by the Worldwide Renewable Power Company, China accounted for a unprecedented 63 per cent of world web additions in whole renewable capability — 298 gigawatts of the 473GW whole. Much more extraordinary was its share of year-on-year progress in international additions of web capability, which was 96 per cent. Exclude China and 2023’s web additions of renewable capability had been a mere 7GW larger than in 2022. Numerous phrases may very well be used to explain such progress, however “exponential” is just not one in every of them.
The issue is that we want speedy progress in renewable funding in all places, not simply in China. In truth, once we break down the “international” power transition into its part regional elements, the issue appears to be like starker nonetheless.
Take into account Africa and Asia-excluding-China. These areas have essentially the most urgent want for funding in low-carbon power sources. Their energy sectors are among the many world’s most fossil-fuel intensive and they’re anticipated to steer international progress in electrical energy consumption. But they’ve solely restricted funding in renewable capability. Between 2018 and 2023, annual web additions of renewable capability grew by a compound annual charge of 10 per cent globally, however solely by 5 per cent in Africa. Examine that with 16 per cent in China. The tempo of progress is slowest exactly the place it’s wanted most.
And so, a number of a long time after governments world wide started to take measures to actively help renewables funding, greenhouse-gas emissions from electrical energy era — the only largest supply of anthropogenic emissions but in addition the one factor that we all know how one can simply decarbonise — proceed to climb.
Debunking the “exponential progress” narrative is essential not simply because it’s deceptive in as far as it errors a Chinese language story for a world one. It is usually essential as a result of the narrative is politically salient and harmful.
If we’re reaching exponential progress with our current approaches, why would we modify something about how we’re presently going about issues? Exponential progress bespeaks success, not failure.
Certainly, the narrative of exponential progress in renewables underpins a slew of Pollyanna-ish current books that implicitly or explicitly endorse what are largely business-as-usual approaches to the local weather disaster. Extra particularly, they endorse what passes for enterprise as typical within the bulk of the world outdoors China, the place, after all, enterprise as typical appears to be like notably completely different.
Decarbonising electrical energy era as quickly and as broadly as potential absolutely ranks as one in every of humanity’s most urgent duties, not least on condition that the electrification of transportation, buildings and trade is on the core of current methods for mitigating international warming kind of in all places.
For higher or worse, coverage and our economies run on narratives. The duty of decarbonising is made tougher, not simpler, when these mischaracterise progress and fail to confront uncomfortable information.